Index > Does anybody know > I don't know who knows > Re: I don't know who knows > It still makes stuff up sometimes, but it's alot smarter than it used to be, and I want to punch it alot less.

Re: It still makes stuff up sometimes, but it's alot smarter than it used to be, and I want to punch it alot less.

Posted by Tabernacles E. Townsfolk (@billstrudel) on Jan. 31, 2025, 8:54 p.m.

I asked ChatGPT to translate the first seven lines of the Iliad into Persian in quantitative hexameter and it told me it was difficult to do so as Farsi is a stress-based language (English has this problem, too – the elegiacs and Asclepiads were specified to be quantitative). I asked it to translate the same seven lines into Persian in some other quantitative form, I don’t remember which. It replied that Persian poetry is quantitative (based on vowel length rather than stressed-unstressed as English does, which is qualitative). I asked how Persian poetry can be quantitative when the language is stress-based and it gave me some gobbledygook.

I think my mistake was that one reply gave Persian as Modern Farsi and the other, Classical Persian. I guess you could specify Farsi, Dari, and Tajik you could have any flavor of Persian you like.