Index > 5 relistens that kicked my ass in high school and took my lunch money > Re: 5 relistens that kicked my ass in high school and took my lunch money > Spoiler for the next one of these posts. > Re: Spoiler for the next one of these posts.

It's the worst thing Pink Floyd has ever done.

Posted by Billdude (@billdude) on Dec. 10, 2024, 2:19 p.m.

And I’m not forgetting what I just said about “A Saucerful Of Secrets,” nor am I forgetting “Take It Back” or any of the many turds on A Momentary Lapse Of Reason.

The gap in quality between AMH’s title track and “Echoes” is stunning, particularly since I think “Echoes” is likely their best song.
Really the AMH suite sounds like they took the worst of the ASOS, simplified it, and then stretched it out to 23 minutes.

“If” is a great song. I’ve always thought so. It’s just about the only thing I’ve listened to from this album outside of when I listened to the album in the first place 15 years or so.
“Alan’s Psychedelic Breakfast” I haven’t really listened to since, but I know I defended it back in the day and it has a prettiness to it that I like.
“Summer ‘68” and “Fat Old Sun” then are the wild cards.
But it’s definitive that AHM suite is turdburglary .