Tommy Lee Jones was going to be my pick (for some reason, he was bald when he accepted his Oscar at age 46), he was 23 in his first film appearance in Love Story in 1970 and already looked 35. James Gandolfini was only 31 in True Romance. Caroll O’Connor was around 46 when All In The Family started. Mark E. Smith looked horrible before he was 50.

I remember seeing lots of means pointing out that either Tom Cruise or Paul Rudd is “now the same age as Wilford Brimley in Cocoon!!!”