Posted by Tabernacles E. Townsfolk (@billstrudel) on Dec. 16, 2024, 6:44 p.m.
Some of these can be reduced to “first three good albums” before they turned to crap. They might not be great, but I’d take any of these over, say, R.E.M.
AC/DC: Powerage/Highway to Hell/Back in Black/For Those About to Rock (take your pick. A lot of reviewer types trash About to Rock but it’s iconic, got a lot of bangers, and peak Brian Johnson)
Bathory: Under the Sign of the Black Mark/Blood Fire Death/Hammerheart (the s/t is so good and iconic it deserves to be on here but the album after it wasn’t great)
Darkthrone: A Blaze in the Northern Sky/Under a Funeral Moon/Transilvanian Hunger
Bee Gees: Main Course/Children of the World/Saturday Night Fever soundtrack (only five songs on the double-album soundtrack are by the Bee Gees so maybe consider it an EP? George savaged the follow-up, Spirits Having Flown. It’s not that bad, but it’s not great, either, so maybe these guys don’t belong here)
Black Grape: a three-album band, although their third is enjoyable only in an Uncle Dysfunktional way.
Black Sabbath: Black Sabbath/Paranoid/Master of Reality
Blue Öyster Cult: Blue Öyster Cult/Tyranny & Mutation/Secret Treaties
The Eall: Live at the Witch Trials (if you prefer it/Dragnet/Grotesque/Slates (if you prefer it)
Cream: I guess Fresh Cream isn’t the best, so this is a nominee for a notable three-album band
Bowie: Station to Station/Low/”Heroes”
Donovan: A Gift from a Flower to a Garden/The Hurdy-Gurdy Man/Barabajagal
Flaming Lips: Hit to Death in the Future Head/Transmissions from the Satellite Heart/Clouds Taste Metallic
Metallica: Ride the Lightning/Master of Puppets/…And Justice for All
The Jesus & Mary Chain; Psychocandy/Darklands/Automatic (these all rule, fuck you Billdude)
Kraftwerk: Trans-Europe Express/The Man-Machine/Computer World
Leonard Cohen: The Songs of Leonard Cohen/Songs from a Room/Songs of Love and Hate
Limp Bizkit: Three Dolla Bill Y’all/Significant Other/Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavored Water (they’re too stupid to use hyphens)/Results May Vary (take your pick)
Mike Oldfield: Tubular Bells/Hergest Ridge/Ommadawn (an obvious one I didn’t see mentioned)
Motörhead: Overkill/Ace of Spades/Iron Fist
Nazz, Neu!, Nick Drake (other three-album bands, but Nazz is a bit naff)
Of Montreal: Satanic Panic in the Attic/The Sunlandic Twins/Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?
The Orb: The Orb’s Adventures Beyond the Ultraworld/U.F.Orb/Orbus [sic] Terrarum
Pulp: His ‘n’ Hers/Different Class/This Is Hardcore (I will die on this hill)
Slayer: Reign in Blood/South of Heaven/Seasons in the Abyss)
Todd Rundgren: Something/Anything? - A Wizard/A True Star - Todd
Ulver: a great three-album band nobody here cares about or would like
Village People: Macho Man/Cruisin’/Go West (unlike Limp Bizkit, I’m dead serious – great campy disco albums that don’t take themselves at all seriously. They were in on the joke)
I’m not going to mention Yes or VU. What’s the point?
- Re: Some that others haven't mentioned (I think) - Joe H. Dec. 21 3:48 PM
-
Suprised you didn't suggest -
Norville
Dec. 20 10:46 AM
- Re: Suprised you didn't suggest - Tabernacles E. Townsfolk Dec. 22 7:53 AM
- I agree with your picks for Slayer - John S Dec. 16 9:02 PM
-
Re: Some that others haven't mentioned (I think) -
Joe
Dec. 16 9:01 PM
-
Re: Re: Some that others haven't mentioned (I think) -
Billdude
Dec. 19 12:46 PM
-
You dont check RYM? -
Ken
Dec. 19 5:36 PM
-
Re: You dont check RYM? -
Billdude
Dec. 19 11:23 PM
- Re: Re: You dont check RYM? - Ken Dec. 20 2:43 AM
-
Re: You dont check RYM? -
Billdude
Dec. 19 11:23 PM
-
You dont check RYM? -
Ken
Dec. 19 5:36 PM
-
Re: Re: Some that others haven't mentioned (I think) -
Tabernacles E. Townsfolk
Dec. 17 8:52 AM
-
I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Joe
Dec. 17 7:43 PM
-
Re: I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Tabernacles E. Townsfolk
Dec. 18 5:59 PM
-
Re: Re: I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Joe
Dec. 19 12:36 PM
-
Re: Re: Re: I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Tabernacles E. Townsfolk
Dec. 20 6:55 AM
- Re: Re: Re: Re: I am pretty fond of Bomber. - Joe Dec. 21 12:40 PM
-
Re: Re: Re: I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Tabernacles E. Townsfolk
Dec. 20 6:55 AM
-
Re: Re: I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Joe
Dec. 19 12:36 PM
-
I think Bomber is a terrific album -
John S
Dec. 17 10:09 PM
- I think they're most *interesting* three album run is - Joe Dec. 18 7:56 AM
-
Re: I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Tabernacles E. Townsfolk
Dec. 18 5:59 PM
- Funkadelic - Let's Take It To The Stage (nt) - Mod Lang Dec. 17 12:52 PM
-
I am pretty fond of Bomber. -
Joe
Dec. 17 7:43 PM
-
Re: Re: Some that others haven't mentioned (I think) -
Billdude
Dec. 19 12:46 PM